What's the Takeaway for Your Reader?

Try this: tell someone what your piece is about.

Not the plot, not the premise, not the surface argument. What it's about. The thing underneath. The reason it needed to exist in the first place.

If you stumble — if you open your mouth and hear yourself say something that surprises you, or something that feels hollow, or nothing coherent at all — congratulations. You've just discovered a useful editing tool, one that costs nothing and requires no software.

The deeper subject of a piece of writing tends to stay hidden for most of the drafting process. You think you know what you're making. You may even have an outline. But the real gravitational center, the subterranean thing the whole piece is actually circling, often doesn't reveal itself until you're nearly done. This is not a failure. This is how writing works.

The problem comes when writers try to edit before they've excavated that center. They tighten sentences. They cut adverbs. They move paragraphs around like furniture. And the piece still feels wrong, because they're decorating a room without knowing what the room is for.

Speak the piece aloud to another person, or to yourself, or to a voice memo on your phone. Explain what it's doing, not what happens in it. What it wants the reader to feel or understand or question by the time they reach the last line.

Notice where you reach for words and don't find them. Notice where you over-explain, which usually means you don't quite believe what you're saying. Notice where something comes out of your mouth that wasn't in the draft at all — that unwritten sentence might be what you've been circling.

Now go back to the draft with that knowledge in hand.

Suddenly the editing questions become answerable. Does this paragraph serve the real subject, or the subject you thought you were writing about in week one? Does this scene earn its length, or is it furniture? Does the ending land where the piece always wanted to go, or where you steered it out of habit or fear?

Knowing what you're writing about tells you what belongs and what doesn't. It tells you when a section is done. It tells you (and this is the one writers most desperately need) when you're finished.

More Tips